Guides

Mistake on a filed 83(b) election: correct or revoke?

What can still be fixed after an 83(b) election is filed, what cannot, and the IRS procedure for revocation.

By Yann LephayPublished · Last updated

Summary

Our answer: it depends on the calendar. While the 30-day election window is still open, Rev. Proc. 2006-31 says a request to revoke will generally be granted, whatever the reason, and a corrected election can still be filed within the same window. After day 30, the election can be revoked only with IRS consent, which Treas. Reg. 1.83-2(f) limits to a mistake of fact about the underlying transaction, requested within 60 days of discovering it, through the letter-ruling procedure. Misunderstanding the vesting terms or the tax result is not a mistake of fact, and neither is a fall in value.

Rev. Proc. 2006-31: revocation generally granted if requested within the 30-day election window; after it, only a mistake of fact about the underlying transaction, requested within 60 days of discovery (Treas. Reg. 1.83-2(f)).

Within 30 days of the transferRevocation generally grantedRev. Proc. 2006-31, section 3.08 and example 2.
After 30 daysMistake of fact onlyAbout the underlying transaction; within 60 days of discovery (Treas. Reg. 1.83-2(f)).
Not a mistake of factValue drop, misunderstanding forfeiture terms or tax effectRev. Proc. 2006-31, sections 2.05-2.07.
ProcedureLetter-ruling requestWith the election date, a copy, the mistake and its discovery date.
83(b) Election DeskNot for correction or revocationThe wizard stops on revoking, undoing, amending or late-filing questions.

Our verdict

The date decides. Before day 30, the IRS generally grants a revocation requested inside the window, and a new election can still be filed. After day 30, the bar is narrow (a mistake of fact about the transaction itself, raised within 60 days) and the procedure is a letter ruling, which a tax professional should handle.

Who this page is for, and who it is not for

For: people who filed an 83(b) election and found an error or changed their mind. Not for: people who have not filed yet (prepare it carefully once) or who missed the 30-day deadline altogether (no election was made).

What the IRS treats as a mistake of fact

Rev. Proc. 2006-31 gives four examples.

Rev. Proc. 2006-31 examples (IRS, effective June 13, 2006)
SituationTimingOutcome
Employee misunderstood the forfeiture terms and the tax resultWithin 60 days of understanding, after the 30-day windowNot granted: not a mistake of fact
Same employeeRequest filed inside the 30-day election windowGranted, whatever the reason
Received Class B shares instead of the Class A shares agreedWithin 60 days of discovering itGranted: mistake of fact about the transaction
Same, discovered the same wayMore than 60 days after discoveryNot granted

What a revocation request contains

The request follows the letter-ruling procedure and must include the date of the election, a copy of it, a description of the mistake of fact about the underlying transaction, and the date the mistake first became known. If it is made inside the 30-day window, the request must say so. A granted revocation takes effect as of the date of the election.

Common questions

Can I revoke an 83(b) election?

Only with IRS consent (IRC 83(b)(2)). Rev. Proc. 2006-31 says consent will generally be granted if the request is filed on or before the due date for making the election, the 30th day after the transfer. After that, consent requires a mistake of fact about the underlying transaction, requested within 60 days of discovering it.

I put the wrong number of shares on my 83(b). What now?

Inside the 30-day window, Rev. Proc. 2006-31 says a revocation request will generally be granted, and a new election can still be filed before day 30. After day 30, whether the error is a mistake of fact about the transaction, and what to request, are questions for a tax professional.

The shares lost value. Can I undo the election?

It depends on the date. If the 30-day election window is still open, Rev. Proc. 2006-31 (section 2.08 and example 2) says a revocation request filed within it will generally be granted, whatever the reason. After the window closes, a decline in value does not qualify: Treas. Reg. 1.83-2(f) and Rev. Proc. 2006-31 both say that a mistake as to the value, or a decline in value, is not a mistake of fact.

Does 83(b) Election Desk file a revocation request?

No. Revoking, undoing, amending or replacing a filed election is outside the product, and the wizard stops on these questions. Revocation requests follow the IRS letter-ruling procedure; a tax professional should handle them.

Not filed yet? Check the packet fit

Correcting, replacing or revoking an election you already filed is outside 83(b) Election Desk: the wizard stops on these questions, so take them to a tax professional. The $49 packet is for people who have not filed yet.

Open checker